https://guitarnoise.forum/news/riaa-challenges-youtube-and-googlevideo-over-video-distribut/ Guitar Noise Discussion Board en-US Thu, 04 Jun 2026 19:38:50 +0000 wpForo 60 https://guitarnoise.forum/news/riaa-challenges-youtube-and-googlevideo-over-video-distribut/paged/3/#post-188008 Sat, 08 Jul 2006 00:45:58 +0000 News Steve-0 https://guitarnoise.forum/news/riaa-challenges-youtube-and-googlevideo-over-video-distribut/paged/3/#post-188008 https://guitarnoise.forum/news/riaa-challenges-youtube-and-googlevideo-over-video-distribut/paged/3/#post-188006 Sat, 08 Jul 2006 00:36:18 +0000
Dog - I think you got it right]]> News cnev https://guitarnoise.forum/news/riaa-challenges-youtube-and-googlevideo-over-video-distribut/paged/3/#post-188006 https://guitarnoise.forum/news/riaa-challenges-youtube-and-googlevideo-over-video-distribut/paged/3/#post-187999 Fri, 07 Jul 2006 23:23:52 +0000
I think That puts it nicely in a nut shell 8) --the dog]]> News smokindog https://guitarnoise.forum/news/riaa-challenges-youtube-and-googlevideo-over-video-distribut/paged/3/#post-187999 https://guitarnoise.forum/news/riaa-challenges-youtube-and-googlevideo-over-video-distribut/paged/3/#post-187997 Fri, 07 Jul 2006 22:50:55 +0000
I wouldn't worry too much about people recording audio from such sources, for a couple of reasons: it's too much of a pain for the average Joe, the sound quality on YouTube videos is nothing to write home about and it's a lot simpler to download the stuff off p2p.

I see this particular matter as defining - to some extent - the phonographic industry's view with regard to use of recordings. Remember, if we were to take literally the typical copyright blurb on CDs, we should not be playing them for friends (not at parties certainly, as it would amount to public broadcast :) ), let alone lending them to said friends or selling stuff we no longer want. As for setting precidents - I am a great believer in common sense. If a given activity is of little threat to the copyright holders' rights (and clearly these are not people who are out to make money off these videos - especially since it's highly unlikely there's money to be made), then setting out to stomp it down with all guns blazing seems something of an overreaction. What the RIAA should be doing is pursuing those who violate copyright for commercial gain. There is a difference and the two activities should be treated differently.]]> News Faza https://guitarnoise.forum/news/riaa-challenges-youtube-and-googlevideo-over-video-distribut/paged/3/#post-187997 https://guitarnoise.forum/news/riaa-challenges-youtube-and-googlevideo-over-video-distribut/paged/3/#post-187916 Fri, 07 Jul 2006 07:51:09 +0000 News TwistedLefty https://guitarnoise.forum/news/riaa-challenges-youtube-and-googlevideo-over-video-distribut/paged/3/#post-187916 https://guitarnoise.forum/news/riaa-challenges-youtube-and-googlevideo-over-video-distribut/paged/3/#post-187912 Fri, 07 Jul 2006 07:09:02 +0000 News U2Bono269 https://guitarnoise.forum/news/riaa-challenges-youtube-and-googlevideo-over-video-distribut/paged/3/#post-187912 https://guitarnoise.forum/news/riaa-challenges-youtube-and-googlevideo-over-video-distribut/paged/3/#post-187780 Thu, 06 Jul 2006 16:38:25 +0000
Don't forget that it isn't about the exact situation but about what *could* happen. If they'd publicy allow this it could get them into big, big legal issues.]]> News Ignar Hillström https://guitarnoise.forum/news/riaa-challenges-youtube-and-googlevideo-over-video-distribut/paged/3/#post-187780 https://guitarnoise.forum/news/riaa-challenges-youtube-and-googlevideo-over-video-distribut/paged/3/#post-187776 Thu, 06 Jul 2006 16:13:21 +0000
your example is probably correct if the video is obviously just people goofing off or having fun, but if it was the "Laker Girls" or some known entity using copyrighted music then you have a whole new situation for the RIAA to sink their greedy teeth into.]]> News TwistedLefty https://guitarnoise.forum/news/riaa-challenges-youtube-and-googlevideo-over-video-distribut/paged/3/#post-187776 https://guitarnoise.forum/news/riaa-challenges-youtube-and-googlevideo-over-video-distribut/paged/3/#post-187751 Thu, 06 Jul 2006 10:25:44 +0000
What I'm getting at is that maybe the RIAA are getting too worked up about it. These are not music videos. They do actually offer increased exposure for the songs in question. Isn't this action actually doing more damage than good?]]> News Faza https://guitarnoise.forum/news/riaa-challenges-youtube-and-googlevideo-over-video-distribut/paged/3/#post-187751 https://guitarnoise.forum/news/riaa-challenges-youtube-and-googlevideo-over-video-distribut/paged/3/#post-187574 Wed, 05 Jul 2006 03:17:25 +0000
Peace 8)]]> News Anonymous https://guitarnoise.forum/news/riaa-challenges-youtube-and-googlevideo-over-video-distribut/paged/3/#post-187574